Behind The Built Environment Episode 29
The US Data Centre Boom: Opportunities, Challenges And Lessons For UK Contractors
The US is experiencing an extraordinary construction boom, driven by investment in data centres, advanced manufacturing and infrastructure. But as demand accelerates, contractors face growing pressure to secure the workforce, skills and resources needed to deliver.
In this special live episode of Behind The Built Environment, David Frise, Chief Executive of BESA, speaks with Tim Brink, Chief Executive of the Mechanical Contractors Association of America (MCAA), and Brian Hughes, MCAA Past President and President of Hughes Environmental Engineering.
Tim and Brian explain how the rapid expansion of data centres is transforming the US construction market, shifting priorities from cost to speed and capacity. They explore the challenges of managing growth, maintaining profitability and developing a skilled workforce, and what UK contractors can learn from the American experience.
This episode covers:
- The scale of US investment in data centres and the implications for construction
- Why delivery speed and workforce capacity are overtaking price as commercial priorities
- The impact of major projects on smaller contractors, labour availability and supply chains
- How US contractors and trade unions collaborate to develop skilled workforces
- The importance of project management training in delivering profitable projects
- How AI could transform contractor efficiency, pricing transparency and customer relationships
- The role of maintenance, commissioning and whole-life building performance
- Building safety, workforce wellbeing and the pressures created by accelerated construction programmes
The discussion also considers community resistance to data centre developments, differences in UK and US regulation, and the importance of fair wages, working conditions and long-term respect for skilled trades.
Watch Now
David: Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to a live edition of Behind the Built Environment. And to prove that it's live, we have a live audience. Are you all alive? Yes. Excellent. I'm David Frise, Chief Executive of BESA. Today we're looking across the Atlantic at the opportunities opening up for our industry and what it takes to make the most of them.
There's a lot of excitement around American investment in data centres, manufacturing, and infrastructures. But a big pipeline of projects raises a fairly basic question: who is going to deliver them? And for the contractor, there's another question: can you grow the business without losing control of it? To help us explore that, I'm delighted to welcome Tim Brink, Chief Executive of the Mechanical Contractors Association of America, MCAA, and Brian Hughes, past President of MCAA and President of Hughes Environmental Engineering.
So welcome, Tim. Welcome, Brian.
Tim: Thank you for having us. Thank you.
David: Live audience reaction. That's great. To kick off, we always ask one basic question at the beginning. Did you choose the career or did the career choose you? And I'll start with Tim.
Tim: Like Brian, I'm a product of a family business that's been— my grandfather started our family business in LA in 1924. And I joined the family business when I graduated from college in 1986, and I started my career then. So it found me.
David: We hear that one a lot. Brian?
Brian: Yeah, similar story. My company was founded in 1935 by my grandfather and great-grandfather just outside of New York City. I knew my grandfather growing up as a kid, although we never worked together because he had passed away before I came to the business. But definitely, decidedly, the business chose me. I don't know that it chose wisely, but I did get chosen.
David: Thank you. This is about the boom in the work in the States, and we hear a lot about the US engineering services boom. What does it actually look like from where you're sitting, Tim, and how widely are your members feeling it?
Tim: Well, the semiconductor and data centre industry in the US is truly booming. And to respond to that, recently we formed a hyperscale data centre task force. We've got some of our largest contractors, our key staff, and we are meeting regularly with the hyperscalers— Google, Meta, Microsoft, AWS— to help bring a little more transparency and a little more engagement from them with our contractors so we can predict what's going to come in the next 6 months because it's already changing.
They have an aggressive growth trajectory. One of them, just for an example, Meta, took them 11 years to place 3 gigawatts of data centre capacity. This year alone, they'll place 8. For a total of 11. By the end of 2030, they want to be at 50, and all 4 of them have similar aspirations.
So the boom is just incredible.
David: And this is everywhere, all at once, every region?
Tim: And they think they can just throw money at it and people will pop up and material and equipment and everything else will just show up on their job sites.
David: And does that match your view, Brian, of
Brian: I concur, David. You know, Tim and I have crisscrossed the United States for our jobs, visiting all sorts of regions, and I include Canada in that as well. And I, even as a contractor, I was told before I travelled for the MCAA what to expect, and I was still taken aback on just the vast volume of construction going on.
I've never seen anything like this. You can maybe debate the exact numbers, but I think we have about 3,200 data centres built, Under construction right now, and they're saying another maybe 1,200 or more coming up in the next few years. But who really knows? I think from an economic outlook in the U.S., the pessimists are saying this is going to be another three-year run.
The optimists say seven or more. So does it really matter who's right? It's at least three. But it's it's pretty breathtaking to just see the scale. of what's happening. I'm stunned, but it's real. For what you read about, it's actually happening.
Tim: I will say, and I will give all 4 of those organizations credit, that they are engaging with the people that need to build their facilities, and they're trying to bring that transparency to our members so that they can prepare for it, so they can get the manpower and lined up so they can get their project managers, their field leaders, their senior executives, their teams enhanced so they can handle this kind of work.
Because I did say that they just want to throw money at it, but they also want to throw partnership and collaboration in there so they can actually achieve their goals.
David: So you mentioned throwing money at it. I recall from the conference in Phoenix earlier in the year, People were saying that it's flipped the economic model. So it's not about the price anymore, it's about have you actually got the capacity to deliver this on time? Is that your experience, Brian?
Brian: Yeah, you know, from a contractor's perspective, we've lived our lives with the economic viability being the primary driver of a construction project. Is the budget there? What's your price? Can you do it? And that's not Construction cost has always been a primary driver of the decision whether a project went forward and if we were awarded that project.
That's that's not their concern anymore. Speed is probably number one. Availability of land, availability of power, water—we can get into some of those other things—but the the cost of construction, which always was a very important, if not the important thing, which determined whether we got hired, now is much further down the list.
And When Google asks you, hey, instead of this project being delivered in January of 2027 or January of 2028, what would the price be if you could deliver it in July of 2027? And we say, you don't want to know what the cost would be. And they say, yeah, we do want to know and we're serious.
So it's about speed. Now I'm a contractor, so I'm okay with them throwing money at us. Absolutely. We're okay with the throwing money, but they expect our AI And that's the challenge, is to deliver it. The money can be there, but you have to deliver. And that's really what's happening in the US market with data centres.
David: And is that to the detriment of other sectors? Is other work suffering from that?
Tim: Absolutely. Where the data centres are located, it changes the local market. Oftentimes, these hyperscalers will come in and offer very, very low rents. incentives for people to travel into the area and to work on the job sites. And that outprices the other work in the area, the hospital work, the schools, all the regular construction work that has been our bread and butter work that has developed the industry and sustained it in a local market suffers.
David: Is there a political kickback? We're starting to read in the UK that the anti-data centre Intent is beginning to surface. Are you seeing that on projects?
Brian: Yeah, there's a little bit of that where it's kind of grassroots. I think that, and this is just my opinion, it doesn't— as a contractor, not necessarily representing MCAA, some of it is probably the hyperscalers. I think they misjudged the sensitivity of people having a massive construction project in your neighbourhood. I don't think they did a good job educating the general population of how it could increase your tax rolls without filling your schools full of children.
You know, there's a financial benefit for a community to put a data centre in. But don't forget, you know, Amazon, Google, Meta, these are companies that are so well-funded, they've never had to take direction from anybody. They tell everybody what their opinion is, and then we follow it along. And I think that they probably assumed that there would be no resistance because there never has been to any of those companies in anything that they've done.
Now that you say, well, we're going to put this billion-dollar project in your neighbourhood, now there's some pushback. And now I think it'll eventually go away in the US because they're going to do what they always did, which is buy off the community. So I think it's going to happen, but they'll just— If the grassroots resistance in the community says, I'm not having this data centre here, They have to understand it's going somewhere else then.
So negotiate properly. And if it's just not going to happen in your town, okay. But we are seeing a little bit of pushback. And this has really just been this year?
Tim: Yes.
Brian: I would say a year ago, you wouldn't have needed to ask that question. But we are seeing that. And you might see that here in the UK as the hyperscalers start driving money It's, it's not always a guarantee just because they announce it. It may not come.
Tim: They're very keen on community involvement now. One of the, the big asks in each of our meetings with the hyperscalers is involvement from our political action department to, to put together information that our local associations can use at the community meetings when a, when a data centre is coming to a community, actual knowledge of what happens with the water on the job, what's the noise level, what benefits do these companies bring to the community?
Because they'll build community centres, they'll build parks, they'll enhance community areas and give back to a community. And all of this is being clouded by misinformation in social media. A lot of it's true, but a lot of it isn't. And so bringing to light what actually goes on in these buildings.
David: It's not about the facts, it's how you feel about the facts.
Tim: Yes.
Brian: Well, the two, you know, the two biggest objections to a data centre in a particular geographic area is one, the electric, and people that don't see how it's happening are saying, well, once this data centre flips the switch, all the lights are gonna dim in the entire town. And that's not, that probably had some truth to it years ago, but these, the scope of these data centres is so big, they can't be on the grid.
They can't compete with the local consumer because they're using too much power. They have to self-generate, they have to use natural gas, they really have to have their own independent power source. And the water can be debated depending on where you are. The data centre community has come up with an easy, quick response to say that a golf course will use more water annually than our data centre.
So, but whether you agree with that or not, The point is communication and education to let people know that, yes, it's a construction project, but each community has to decide on what terms they will allow Microsoft to come in and drop their millions.
David: This is great because you're asking and answering my questions.
Brian: Oh, you're welcome.
David: Without any input. So a full order book is great, but that doesn't necessarily mean you're profitable. What are the mistakes that you're seeing people make and will make with this full order book?
Tim: From the contractor side?
David: Yeah.
Tim: Misjudging their capacity. The issue and the demands of these projects, they're so large, and the end user is demanding not just, not just a competent project manager, but senior company officers on the job site. And so having, having the right people to be on the job site Enough project managers, enough field leaders is the issue right now.
And that's what we've been asked to rise to the occasion. So we are scaling our project manager education, we're scaling our field leaders education, and we're scaling our top company executive education right now to help them recruit and train more people.
David: So you effectively have to deposit your soul on reception and collect it again in 2 years when you've built the data centre. Is that how it works? Yes.
Brian: Well, listen, David, As contractors, we have this terrible habit of getting the work first and figuring out how to put it in later. And we have been guilty of that for our entire careers. And you can't approach that in this market, at least not in the US. That is how bad things happen to good contractors when you take that old-fashioned approach.
I get it. We've all been there. But that rule will end badly if you apply
David: it. And the optimism bias creeps in and you go, well, I know we've messed it up before, but this time it will be fine.
Tim: Right.
David: One of the unique things about the US is your partnership with the UA, the union, and Mark McManus in particular. How are you able to scale the workforce? But first of all, could you explain how it works? Because it's a different model from the UK.
Brian: You could take that one.
Tim: Yeah. In the US, our partnership with the UA, his motto is, what he says all the time is they provide well-trained, quality craftspeople to union signatory contractors. So what that means is they have 280-some-odd local unions across the country, and each local union has its own training centre, and they train the craftsperson in the basic skills of piping skills.
So when our contractors, our contractor members need help in a local area, they call the local hall and they ask for a certain number of journeymen and a certain number of apprentices to be dispatched, and they come out with a base level of skills. So, and I know it's different here in the UK, the training is on the contractor for the most part.
There, the training's on the UA. They provide the craft-level training.
David: So how do you manage that craft workforce, Brian? How does that work in practice as a contractor?
Brian: Really, you have to match the work that you're taking on with the skill sets of the people that the union provides. If you bid a job that requires some sort of specialty, you know, stainless welding, and they don't have that capability, you either don't take on that work or you tell them you need to find somebody and train.
The other thing to add on to what Tim said is that the way the training is funded in the US is that The hourly worker has an assessment against his paycheck in order to fund a school. It's almost like tuition. So yes, school is free, but the the union membership has agreed to tax themselves in order to fund a school to run their apprenticeship through, so that the person comes out.
We call it turning out as a journeyman or journey worker, and will now be be skilled. So you have to be careful not to. to take on something that your skilled workforce can't handle. It's the same thing with service. You're not going to promise something to an existing building customer that the customer is not trained for it.
And as contractors, we do typically supplement the union training with maybe some specialty factory training, right? Mitsubishi is one of your sponsors here. So if we need specialty training just on Mitsubishi and our school locally in Dallas, Texas, Los Angeles, Atlanta, doesn't have it, we will find that somewhere else because you don't want to break a promise to a customer.
David: So how are you going to scale up the workforce to meet this demand and who's going to pay for it?
Tim: Well, the nice thing about having a great partnership with the UA is they sit on the hyperscale task force with us. They're in our monthly meetings with the big end users, so they're hearing from them what's coming down the road. What projects are coming, and they all have their man loading curves. They all know from experience how many people they're going to need.
So that gives the UA a chance to work with their international reps that are all over the country, work with their organizers to try to develop the workforce and get enough people who want to travel to that area so that so that they can man the jobs. So far, they've done a pretty good job of.
meeting the expectation, but that system is going to be stressed when everybody wants in the next 4 years to develop as much as they have on the books. It's going to be a real challenge, I think.
David: Have you seen an uptick in young people being interested in the apprenticeships?
Brian: Yeah, I would agree. I don't know how your BESA members view it here in the UK, but In the US, we went through an entire generation where, you know, going to a 4-year university degree was the default option. And there was almost kind of a penalty for people that wanted to go into the trades.
That is eroding. And we've seen a noticeable shift in the culture in the US where you're not a second-class citizen if you decide to end your schooling and pick up some tools. I think this generation, not that they're not motivated by money, but they seem to be, and I'm being a little bit of a generalization, a little bit more motivated by quality of life.
And it's not about, you know, when we were coming up, Tim, like we lived to work, right? And we fought each other over Saturday assignments and who got the overtime. Now they work to live. And that shift in culture, I think, has opened the doors We're getting a lot more people looking at our apprenticeships and then they see, because with social media, when you have a 21-year-old who finished his formal education at age 18 and he's pulling in $125,000 a year with benefits, that attracts attention.
That's a good thing. That's a good byproduct of combustion of the changing culture, I think.
David: Can we move on to project management? So away from craft, onto project management. You've for a long time run a school for project management. which has formed into a group and a network, I think. Could you tell us a bit about that and how successful it is?
Tim: We have a program called the Institute for Project Management. We call it the IPM, and it's held in Austin, Texas, at the University of Texas. And we do 4 classes a year, and we have since 1986. When COVID hit, we put in a virtual version of that and called it the Preparatory Institute for Project Management, and we still run that, and we run about four classes of that each year.
And now we're this year, starting next month in November, we're having IPM Dallas, which is a more modern version of IPM Austin because IPM Austin is two weeks in person. IPM Dallas is going to be two weeks. The first week is a combination of self-paced and virtual learning. And the second week will be in person.
And where the traditional IPM is a class of 36, and we do 4 classes a year, IPM Dallas will be a class of 100. And we can scale up to as many as 10 to 12 classes a year. So the goal is to help our members educate their new project managers because they need a lot of them to execute this kind of work.
David: And Brian, you put people through this process?
Brian: Yeah, I've been through some of the IPM. It's pretty slick. You know, you think about as a contractor where the risk is and where things can go wrong. That project management and construction, whether you call it foreman, general foreman, project management, that is the crux of where the difference from P&L, on the P&L, happens is at that project management level.
And it is so critical to have the right skills to manage the job properly. You could do everything right. You could have the best field labor. You could have a great estimate. You could have a great owner, a great customer. But if you don't stick the landing with that project management, everything goes downhill.
And we've, as contractors, a lot of us unfortunately have probably learned lessons of what happens when things go wrong with project management. But the MCaa has really invested heavily in that because it's one of the things that our contractor members most value.
David: Well, we liked it so much, we're trying to replicate it in the UK now, and we launched our first courses in September. Wonderful.
Brian: That's why we have this partnership. We're here to learn from you too, so whatever we can share.
David: So we talked about the building of data centres and AI in effect. How are you seeing AI being used in businesses? What do you think the benefits are and what are the dangers for a contractor?
Brian: You know, with the Mechanical Contractors Association of America, we don't have a formal policy or statement on AI and, you know, if this, then that. It's kind of, it's really an opinion piece because we're seeing things evolve very quickly. I'll share with you and your membership my own experience with AI. You know, sometimes we think about Gee, what can it do for our business?
What can it do to make us more efficient? What can it do to make us more profitable? Is there anything we can do on buying things? But I would encourage all contractors to think of it from a more global scale, like how will AI shift the balance with our customers? Think about how they're going to use AI to do business with us.
You know, historically, our business model as contractors And let's be candid, has been predicated on a certain expertise differential between those that are making the estimates and the decisions, us, and those who are buying it. And there's been a kind of a lack of transparency. It's a little bit opaque with pricing, right?
We don't reveal our markups, we don't reveal our gross margins, we don't reveal our costs. Think about AI as changing the way our customers are smarter buyers. So you're going to have, in my opinion, we could, before we have any advantages as contractors doing business, AI could disrupt, I'll use the verb disrupt, could disrupt the traditional relationship between supplier, manufacturer, contractor, and end user, right?
Like right now we're a little smarter than they are, okay? For lack of a better phrase. That may change and be on guard for how AI empowers our customers to disrupt the supply chain and force transparency where right now it doesn't exist. But we don't think of it that way because it's always been that way.
And the ground could shift under us and it might not be our businesses, it could be the customers.
David: Tim, you got anything to add?
Tim: I've watched our— just what happens in our own office at MCaa. We're using AI to gather information, gather meeting notes, gather committee notes and everything else and keep everybody on task. It's up to us to have the knowledge and the skill set to execute everything. But it's like having an assistant that's keeping your calendar, keeping you updated on all of the critical items that you haven't completed, yet.
And we're watching that happen in, in the offices of our members as well. And the nice thing about having this Hyperscale Task Force is we're dealing with the Googles, we're dealing with the Microsofts, we're dealing with the Metas who are developing all of these AI systems. And they're educating us on how to use them, which is phenomenal.
So we're getting firsthand knowledge from the creators of Google Gemini or from Copilot on how they can enhance our business. And it's, it's from our staff level that is participating in it, in those meetings, and the contractors. We're already seeing advantages from it.
David: Apropos of nothing, these— we don't normally hold the microphones. These are heavy. It's like doing a workout, isn't it? And the second, the overzealous use of the Pritt Stick means all the questions have stuck together, which doesn't always happen. Brian, you also have a service and maintenance side to your business. Are they involved early enough, do you think, in the design and the handover of the building, or do you just get it at the end and go, there you go, now maintain that?
Brian: Well, you know, there's always been that mild friction, David, between those who install it and those who have to service it. Those who design and install generally are not open-minded to the opinions of those that have to service. So, no, I think that the industry has a long way to come to bring in to say, you know, is that really the right place we want to put that access hatch in there?
And the service company would say, no, if you can put it over there, because it'll save us from sending a second man to hold the ladder for the next 20 years. So those kind of things. So there's always a little bit of that push-pull between— They who design and build, and they who service and maintain.
I get that. But you know, getting involved in the commissioning, I think good owners generally understand you don't want to tag your end user with an inherent a construction, maybe shortcut, where they go back and say, you know, they knew that all along back in 2026, and now in 2030, I'm still dealing with the way that pipe was run.
Or the way that valve was installed, so I think it goes well. But with service and maintenance, you know, I explain to contractors in the U.S., my peers, I said, you know, regardless of how you feel about whether you want to invest in a service and maintenance entity downstream of your construction business, the same truism holds in the U.K.
and the U.S. The existing building market. never gets smaller. So when you think about the ups and downs of construction, you know, and right now things are up, the trajectory of service and maintenance will always go up, always.
David: And dwarfs the capital cost of the initial install for the whole life cost. I think most builders in this country say access hatch, why do you need one of those?
Brian: Yeah, they just sheetrock the ceiling right over and then we give them a change order to put one in.
David: So a couple of generalist questions, then we're going to go to the audience. So think up your questions, please. What's one assumption about the US market that a British contractor would get wrong, do you think? Silence is an answer.
Brian: I don't want to assume what your assumptions are. That might That might be a better question over a cold beer, which may happen anyway later on. I'm not sure, how would you answer that? Assumptions?
Tim: I think the service industry in the UK is more regulated. The program, the software that you developed to track every item in a building that has to be legally serviced on a regular basis, that doesn't exist in the US. So the one of the assumptions may be that that the service industry is the same there, where there's no requirement for buildings to service their equipment like there is here.
I think that's one advantage that the contractors here in the UK have over the the contractors in the in the US is that there's no requirement over there to have a regular service schedule on. Every piece of equipment in a building. Yeah,
Brian: that's not the US way to do things. You know, there's, there's code, right? Particularly with plumbing and potable water and fire protection and those things. But in the US, there is probably a lower barrier to entry to get into the business if you're good with some tools and you can sit for a license.
And licensing is stronger in certain US states And others, it's, you know, if you could get a business card printed, you're in business. So we do have a lower barrier to entry, and there is some good and bad, you know, depending on, you know, incumbents protect their own market, let's be fair. But there is a lower barrier to entry to be in this industry.
In the US, our government Department of Labor classifies all businesses by something called an SIC code, Standard Industrial Classification. So all hotels like this one that we're in will have a certain SIC code. And plumbing, heating, and cooling contractors, we all have the same SIC code for MCA members or not. And the average employee count in the United States is 9.
9. So it's per business unit. So it is an extremely fragmented business. You know, I consider my business a small business with only 100 employees, but it's still larger than the average rank-and-file plumber. His wife is doing the books, he's working out of the house. That's what we look like.
David: By the way, there's somebody in the audience who will happily sell you a standard for maintenance across the piece. So can we do some audience questions now? Do we need to change the cameras at all? Jack? No, we're good. At the back, if you can introduce yourself, who you are, what company you're from, that would be great.
Thank you.
Q1: Thank you, David. My name is Brian Hughes.
Brian: I like you already.
Q1: Thank you very much. Of Derry Building Services. So we're a medium, small to medium contractor in the UK, design and build. I've got so many questions I could talk to you guys over a cold beer. But what we're seeing in the UK at the moment is, is the data centres where generally where America goes, Britain follows.
So the data centres have been announced They're sucking resources at the moment. As a small to medium contractor, that's— I'm losing resource to that. That's another debate we could have. My question is, you said, I think you mentioned it was 3 to 7 years, this programme of hyperscaling. How is that affecting the small to medium contractors within the MCA, and are the larger ones dropping their normal clients to serve this hyperscale?
Because to me, it's not sustainable. You're going to have a resource problem, you're going to have a supply chain problem, and then when this work's over, what are the larger contractors going to do? Are they going to go back to their normal clients? Because people will remember how you treat them in the long term when someone's offering a big check.
Tim: There is a big demand for resources, and with the data centre owners paying incentive— incentives and per diems to attract the people. A lot of our small to mid-sized contractors are losing key people when they come into the market. And that's, it's either they lose 'em or they have to match what the hyperscalers are offering.
There are some markets where contractors are not chasing the data centre work and they're concentrating on all the work that is being left behind. the hospitals, the schools, the commercial buildings, and certain contractors that are doing that are thriving, but they still have to match the salary increases. And we have a rather robust manufacturer supplier membership in MCAA, and we just recently opened it up to attract more people in.
And that's one of our big conversations. with them is, okay, here's what we're— here's what we're learning from the hyperscalers is coming down the pike. Here's the demand for your, your material and equipment. And, and, and we're all trying to look at this together so we can meet the demand. But it's, it's a challenge, and it's— we don't know where it's going to go.
We know where it's going, but we don't know the long-term effects yet.
David: Okay, we go One at the right at the back, Andrew, I think it is.
Q2: Journalist at the back, sorry. So I'm Andrew Gavid from Elemental. I'm a journalist and I'm going to resist. What I really want to talk about is President Trump and what's going on. So what I want to ask you is, over here we're talking a lot about heat pumps and net zero carbon. How is that landing over in the States?
Is that a big thing yet? Is it just a talking point? I know big oil is a bit bigger out there.
Brian: Well, welcome, journalists. You're in the back row where we keep you. And by the way, you know, if you ever think that things are bad in the UK when you look at politics, that we're here for you in the US. Just—
Tim: You're welcome.
Brian: Yeah, you're welcome. Just look over across the Atlantic to what we have to offer and you'll feel a lot better about the UK. Yeah, you talk about the carbon, the regulatory. It's real. It's a real conversation. It appears to be driven more by the regulatory environment than the owner. Some owners will say, I would like to upgrade, I would like this, I would like that, but that's usually in the design phase.
At the contractor level, we generally, at least in the US, we're not seeing that our opinion may count. If anything, they want to say, well, we need to find a way to save some money on this, and what are we going to say? Well, don't go with the highest efficiency. You know, our job is to get it built, not to make the decision and guide the conscience.
But a lot of it is regulatory, particularly around our bigger cities, where I think that they're probably a little bit more progressive thinking politically, and they'll drive that into the regulatory environment. So I work in— for those of you that have been in the US, I work in a very tight area of New York City, New Jersey, and Connecticut.
And I'll find different answers to that question depending on where I'm going to put that same 10-ton heat pump.
David: Our president has a question.
Q3: Thank you, David. Anna Shepherd from NG Raili. We're talking today a lot about compliance and our Building Safety Act. I was wondering if you've got any similar legislative changes sort of forcing you to prove competence or a certain standard of delivery over there.
Tim: Well, we've always had OSHA in the US, which is the government agency that defines the bare minimum standard for safety. We've had that. And what a lot of our local associations are doing and what we're striving to accomplish from a national standpoint is to have an official alliance with OSHA so we can help influence the standards that are coming and help raise the bar.
I can tell you that our partnership with the UA, we put safety first and we put mental health first. And we just had our first ever UAMCA mental health conference this week before we got here. So we're trying to raise the occupational safety level and the psychological safety in the mental health arena in the US, raise it up because It's another byproduct of this data centre work.
They all want it done now, they want it done quickly, and they're going 5/10s, 6/10s, 7/10s, and it wears people out. And you can, you can do that for a short period of time, but it cannot be sustained. And especially when the projects are going into more and more remote areas, you're taking people away from their families.
And you're putting them away from home and working them to death. And you wonder why people— why there's so much burnout.
Brian: We're seeing like a good rule of thumb, and we use the acronym OSHA. The US Department of Labor, within that Department of Labor is the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which is not legislated. It's a government agency. That's what we call OSHA. That is the guiding agency on you know, worker safety out there.
So OSHA has to come investigate when there's a fatality, a dismemberment, or a complaint. And generally a worker complaint, somebody will anonymously say, this is unsafe here. OSHA must send somebody to investigate any of those 3 situations. A good rule of thumb for our industry is for every 50 construction workers on a project, through MEP, you know, multiple discipline trades, you'll probably have one full-time safety person on site for it.
So if you're running a second shift, you will have that person. There's never anybody not there. So it's not uncommon for a hyperscaler site to have a mini city outside the gate of this construction project, which, you know, imagine 2 job trailers just with safety people. It's attached to a small medical clinic where there's a full-time nurse on site.
You're not going to get prescriptions there, but just, you know, a daycare centre. It's really stunning about how they change the construction dynamics, and safety, Anna, is a big part of that.
David: Okay, so final question. You're both kings of the industry for a day. What one thing would you change about the industry that would improve it? I'll start with Brian.
Brian: Well, I'm a contractor, David, so profit. Sorry, did I say the wrong— they laughed. Are we in— any contractors in here would like to make money? Yeah, you know, I think one thing that I would— and it's a change that's happening, and I think that it's a good thing. You know, labor right now in the US has the upper hand and they know it.
And they're letting us know that labor is at a premium. We're seeing— what do you think, about 4.8%, 5% increases across the board in our union contracts? And that's per year. And that's a combination of wages and benefits. They have the upper hand. And I don't— as a contractor, I don't begrudge them.
You know, labor is not the enemy of management. The costs of putting in projects and doing construction is really the burden of the customer. It's not our fault to defend the fact that materials are up, supply chains have pressure on them, that these qualified craftspeople and all the people in the office that support them, they deserve that raise.
And I think that that's a good thing that I'd like to see changed, is that when this cycles through 3 years, 5 years, 7, whenever up comes down, and we've all seen this before in our careers, I hope the thing that changes is a permanent respect and floor under what we do for a living and an appreciation for the people that actually choose to be in this business and not that the business chose you and me.
Right. I hope that people choose the business, not the other way around, that this— hopefully, we'll all be retired when that happens because we have a nice long runway for good times. But that's what I'm hoping for, is that we don't go back to— we as a construction purchasing society don't go back to the old way of viewing our craft.
Tim: It's a good question. And at MTAA, every contractor member has to have a signed collective bargaining agreement with the UA, and that means they have adopted a certain philosophy for how they Treat their craft-level employees. They believe in in in a strong middle class. They believe in taking care of their employees, and that means they get they earn a fair wage and they have good benefits.
And if I could change anything, it would be that I would change the the non-signatory companies out there who take advantage of their employees. They change their their rates from project to project. They classify them as independent contractors, so they don't have to have workers' compensation insurance, they don't have to provide medical insurance, they don't have to provide retirement.
And that drags the overall prices and the competitiveness of our contractors down. You know, there's— leveling the playing field would be something that I would change.
David: Tim Brink, Brian Hughes of the MCAA, thank you very much for joining us today. And to our live audience, thank you for coming in. And I recognize that I'm standing between you and lunch now, but please like, review the podcast of whichever medium you use it. And my name is David Frise, and thank you for listening to Behind the Built Environment.
More Episodes Of Behind The Built Environment
Find All Episodes, Watch, Listen And Subscribe
You can explore all episodes of Behind The Built Environment right here. Watch the conversations in full, listen on the go through your favourite podcast platform, and subscribe to stay up to date with the latest insights shaping our industry.
Whether you want to catch up on past discussions or tune in to the newest releases, it’s all in one place, making it easy to keep connected with the people and ideas driving change across the built environment.
Sign Up To Our Email List
And stay up to date with the Behind The Built Environment podcast









